Does a Pool Add Value? A Cape Cod Seller’s Guide to Smart Outdoor Investments

Pools on Cape Cod mean more than just a way to cool off. For the right buyer, they symbolize a lifestyle of leisure, retreat, and summer memories. But when it comes time to sell your home, is your pool helping or hurting your property’s value?

It depends on how well it’s maintained, how it looks, and how it fits with your home’s overall appeal. On average, pool-related improvements can yield anywhere from a 40% to 75% return on investment. But beyond numbers, the emotional draw of a beautiful pool area can be the edge that helps your home stand out.

Here’s what to know if you’re getting ready to list.

What Buyers See When They See a Pool

Not all pools are created equal. A well-designed, well-kept pool signals pride of ownership and lifestyle value. An outdated, neglected one? It can be read as a burden.

Photo by Mike Crane Photography, Architecture by Neal Adamiak

Cape Cod buyers, especially those shopping for second homes or vacation rentals — often prioritize outdoor living. That includes not just the pool itself, but how the entire space feels. Think ambiance, cleanliness, functionality, and vibe.

In desirable areas like Dennis, Orleans, or Falmouth, a pool that looks like a resort feature rather than a maintenance project) can boost both showings and offers.

Three Ways to Get More Value From Your Pool

Lighting = Atmosphere

One of the simplest upgrades that delivers major visual impact is lighting. Soft LED glows around the waterline, solar garden accents, or lighting on trees can make your backyard feel like a private resort  even if the pool is decades old.

A well-lit pool space can generate a return of 60% to 75%, not just through resale value, but by elevating the emotional response buyers have when touring the home.

Photo by Dan Cutrona, Architecture by Chip Webster Architecture

A Clean Pool Is a Valuable Pool
It’s easy to underestimate the importance of day-to-day maintenance. But cloudy water, rusted filters, or cracked plaster can undermine buyer trust instantly. Sellers who keep their pools in clear, functional condition can typically expect a 50% to 65% return  and fewer price negotiations due to inspection concerns. Even minor repairs (like replacing coping or resealing tile) can dramatically shift a buyer’s perception of how the rest of the home has been cared for.

Furniture & Finishes Matter
You don’t have to spend tens of thousands to transform your pool area. In fact, a few design-forward lounge chairs, neutral cushions, and a clean pool deck can increase the perceived value of your outdoor space.

A well-staged poolside area, especially one that photographs beautifully can deliver up to 75% ROI when it enhances the home’s first impression and lifestyle narrative.

Should You Add a Pool Before Selling?

Photo by Dan Cutrona, Architecture by A3 Architecture

Usually, no. Pools are expensive to build and don’t always match what buyers in your neighborhood expect. But if you already have a pool, improving it can be far more cost-effective than tearing it out or leaving it outdated.

If your home is in a market with strong vacation rental demand or limited access to public beaches, a pool can be a major differentiator. In select neighborhoods, it may be exactly what the next buyer is looking for.

—

Final Takeaway

Pools don’t add value automatically  but the right upgrades and presentation absolutely can. Whether you're staging your home for a lifestyle-driven buyer or simply looking to make your backyard feel more elevated, strategic pool improvements are one of the best ways to boost both emotional appeal and sale price.